Neither, Gentlemen.
Come on, Jack—don't disappoint me!
Nathan alerted me on your post
Its the song, Isle of Hope, Isle of Tears by Brendan Graham.
"CHORUS
Isle of hope, Isle of tears,
Isle of freedom, Isle of fears,
But it's not the Isle
I left behind...
That Isle of hunger, Isle of pain,
Isle you'll never see again
But the Isle of home
Is always on your mind."
So, it has to be New York
Jack.